Not the same setup as I use 2 HDTVs. One is connected via HDMI and the other through a DVI to HDMI cable that is modified to also carry audio. Cable, DVD Player, cable and VCR are also connected to the computer through a TV/FM Haupauge tuner. Audio is patched to my Yamaha sound system via Optical Digital Audio. Cable is also directly connected to both TVs. Gives a lot of options.
By chance is there a DVD in the DVD burner on the computer?
Does your keyboard have media keys that you may hit by accident?
As a first step I'd reset all involved units by totally removing power for a short time.
See this topic for possible reference.
viewtopic.php?f=14&t=2045&hilit=dvd+starts